For present and aspiring actual property buyers and landlords, listening to tenant horror tales may be intimidating. Nevertheless, studying up on nightmare tenants provides useful insights on how you can set your self up for fulfillment when buying, promoting, and managing a rental property. We discovered 13 of the worst horror tales about dangerous tenants so you may plan forward to stop these issues along with your properties.
1. Appearances Can Be Deceiving
If you happen to speak to actual property buyers or landlords about their experiences with tenants, they may usually have tales of tenants who look like type, respectable folks. Actual property dealer Kris Lippi (proprietor of ISoldMyHouse.com) had an expertise with a household who rented a suburban single-family residence in Burlington, Vermont. They appeared like the proper tenants, gainfully employed mother and father with two younger youngsters and a canine.
Sadly, simply two months after shifting in, they stopped paying lease on time and ultimately stopped paying altogether. The daddy had misplaced his job however had hidden that info from his landlord. Every time they had been contacted in regards to the lack of lease, the couple responded with excuses and aggression.
To make issues worse, they severely broken the property. The children drew everywhere in the partitions with crayons, ripped up the carpets, and there have been many damaged home equipment. Their canine ruined hardwood flooring by clawing and urinating in every single place. The home reeked of animal waste and rotting meals when inspections had been carried out. Lastly, Kris needed to evict them after a number of ignored warnings in regards to the property injury and unpaid lease. Even after leaving, they vandalized the house by punching holes in partitions, breaking home windows, and stealing ceiling followers.
Keep away from
Seemingly nice folks and households can grow to be dangerous tenants, costing you hundreds in repairs and misplaced lease. Make certain to totally vet all tenants, even when they initially appear innocent. For instance, William Brown from REI Insiders had an identical expertise to Kris however later discovered that his nightmare tenant had been evicted from their earlier rental. Though studying how you can display tenants could appear tedious and time-consuming, it may prevent hundreds of {dollars} and immense stress from coping with damaging tenants.

Avail rental applicant profile (Supply: Avail)
To make it simple, think about using a property administration service that features tenant screening instruments like Avail. It runs complete background checks, together with prison and eviction historical past and a credit score test. It additionally robotically finds the applicant’s job historical past and rental historical past, and verifies their revenue. You possibly can simply view the outcomes of the tenant display of their renter profile and decide in the event that they’re match to your property.
2. Tenants With Unclear Expectations
Not everybody with dangerous tenant horror tales is a full-time actual property investor or skilled. For instance, when Jovana Durovic (editor-in-chief of homegrounds.co) moved in along with her accomplice, she determined to lease out her property as a supply of passive revenue. She made positive the property was pristine and rented it to a pleasant household. They requested if they may embellish a function wall in the lounge, and Jovana agreed.
Sadly, the tenants wrongly took that to imply they may put a function wall in each room in the home. Shortly after, the tenants had a monetary emergency, and their lease was late. Jovana was lenient due to their emergency, however then the tenants began sending their lease late virtually each month. Lastly, as soon as the tenants left, the home was in an terrible state. There have been botched DIY jobs, hideous decorations, and poor upkeep that led to points with mildew, dampness, and drainage.
Keep away from
Some tenant horror tales don’t occur immediately or immediately. As an alternative, these tenants requested for permission earlier than altering the house and communicated after they had a monetary downside. Though the owner and tenant tried to be cordial, there was no clear, written settlement to stop the tenants from profiting from the owner’s kindness.
This landlord may have averted many issues by scheduling extra frequent, deliberate property checks. Ensure you even have clearly outlined expectations and limitations for issues like making adjustments to the property and submitting lease funds. Many landlords enable tenants to color or add footage on the wall so long as when the tenants transfer out, the condominium is restored to its unique situation.
3. Non-paying Tenants
One actual property investor, Brian Davis of SparkRental, recollects a tenant horror story when it took 11 months to get a non-paying tenant out of his rental property. They used each trick within the ebook to lengthen the eviction, together with telling the court docket choose that the property was not in liveable situation—after that they had carried out appreciable injury to the property. Sadly, the choose believed their tales and favored the tenants over the owner.
When these dangerous tenants had been lastly evicted, they punched by each cupboard and ruined the flooring out of spite. The proprietor in the end needed to give up that property as a write-off loss.
Keep away from
Brian names three errors he made with this rental property:
- Buying a rental property in an especially tenant-friendly jurisdiction, the place each the legal guidelines and the judges at all times facet with renters
- Working with a shoddy property administration firm that didn’t display the tenants totally sufficient
- Failing to double-check the tenant screening course of
Because the proprietor of a rental property, doing due diligence is completely important. Ensure you consider the property you buy, the property administration firm you’re employed with, and your tenant screening processes. Though it could look like loads of work initially, it may forestall a variety of issues that may price months of stress and tens of hundreds of {dollars}.
Authorized eviction course of
To efficiently evict dangerous tenants with out prolonging the method, learn our full information about Evict a Tenant in 7 Steps (+ Free Stop Notices).
4. Loud & Disruptive Tenants
One other comparatively widespread tenant horror story considerations the tenant’s life-style. Jim Olenbush (founding father of AustinRealEstate.com) rented an upscale condominium to a tenant who appeared like a dream—well-spoken, respectable job, and an enthralling character.
Nevertheless, inside a month of shifting in, he started receiving complaints from the neighbors about loud music late into the night time and disturbances. The complaints continued to develop in quantity and severity. It reached a head when one night time, the police needed to be referred to as resulting from a raucous celebration the tenant was throwing, breaching each native ordinances and the lease settlement.
Keep away from
This disaster may have been averted with correct screening, particularly contacting earlier landlords. As well as, it’s key for the owner to determine clear communication channels for tenants to boost considerations. Whereas the behaviors of this nightmare tenant had been surprising, his lack of respect for others locally was a obtrusive pink flag that might have been found with extra due diligence.
Jim Olenbush made particular adjustments in response to this situation. He now features a detailed Neighborhood Residing part in his leasing settlement, outlining the expectations and repercussions. He additionally holds common conferences with all tenants to deal with any potential points and to maintain communication traces open.
5. Chasing Down Hire Funds
One other rental property proprietor, Montana Winchester, had a tenant who was well mannered and pleasant throughout preliminary conferences. Nevertheless, as quickly as he moved in, he began calling at odd hours to complain about every little thing, from the creaky floorboards to the faintest noise from the neighbors. Plus, he made the home appear to be a twister inside weeks of residing on the property. He by no means bothered cleansing up after himself, and each time Montana visited, he’d discover piles of soiled dishes, overflowing trash, and stains on the partitions.
Nevertheless, the most important downside with this tenant was that he by no means paid his lease on time. Montana mentioned, “I needed to chase him down each month like a debt collector, and even then, he’d give you some excuse about his paycheck being delayed or another nonsense. It turned a unending cycle of frustration.”
Keep away from
Along with totally screening your tenants, this downside may have been mitigated by having a clause within the lease about cleanliness and well timed lease funds. Being diligent when choosing a tenant and establishing clear boundaries from the beginning can save an limitless period of time and complications.

TenantCloud’s cell app for lease funds (Supply: TenantCloud)
One other essential method to keep away from chasing tenants for lease funds is by utilizing an automatic on-line lease cost service. This eliminates duties that your tenants should do, like writing you a test or manually sending cost, making the method smoother for each of you.
TenantCloud helps tenants arrange autopay with a number of choices, like a bank card, debit card, or direct deposit. It additionally supplies an app for each the tenant and landlord to simply entry their account, make funds, and see their cost historical past.
6. Creative Tenants
Realtor Eric Bramlett shared a few tenant who didn’t trigger any significantly noticeable issues throughout her keep. Nevertheless, Bramlett was left with a shock when she moved out as he discovered Jackson Pollock-style work everywhere in the home. It seemed extra like an summary artwork exhibit than a well-maintained rental residence.

Jackson Pollock portray (Supply: Britannica)
Keep away from
A straightforward method to forestall this may have been common home checks. These enable landlords to see how the property’s doing and type out any points earlier than they increase. When attainable, intention to construct a powerful landlord-tenant relationship in order that your tenants really feel comfy speaking to you—probably avoiding such a predicament. Ensure you are simply as accountable, communicative, and respectful as you need your tenants to be. When a tenant feels valued and heard, they’re extra more likely to deal with their rented residence with the care it deserves.
7. Fixed Complaints
Leonard Ang, CEO of iProperty Administration, says that essentially the most troublesome tenant he ever handled truly stored an immaculate condominium and by no means made a single upkeep or restore request throughout her whole keep. Nevertheless, she made at the least one criticism per day about different tenants.
The tenant would name for noise complaints, scent complaints, complaints about tenants parking of their assigned parking spots, complaints about tenants “not” parking of their assigned parking spots, and complaints about suspicious packages within the foyer. Leonard would even get complaints in regards to the noise the elevator made.
Because the condominium complicated she lived in was particularly protected, clear, and quiet, solely about 5% of her complaints had been truly authentic points. Leonard determined to personally intervene after a couple of weeks. He sat down along with her over tea and mentioned her complaints. He mentioned, “She appeared like a stunning particular person and was actually apologetic for inflicting a lot bother.” Nevertheless, the subsequent day she referred to as the rental workplace to complain that I had been in her condominium with out giving 24-hour discover.
Finally, this nightmare tenant by no means adopted up on her complaints; she by no means confronted the neighbors, referred to as the police, or took different steps to really get any of those points addressed. She simply wished to complain.
Keep away from
That is an unlucky situation that’s troublesome to foretell or forestall. Dangerous tenants can are available in many alternative types. Nevertheless, Leonard ultimately adjusted to the fixed complaints by establishing a transparent rotation for who needed to reply the telephone when she referred to as and persevering with to foster a constructive relationship along with her.
Ensure you have programs to handle disagreeable tenants and restrict the quantity of stress and time-consuming vitality they require. That is one other reminder that investing in actual property and being a landlord isn’t nearly filling a property, however selecting the best tenant.
8. Tenant Threats
In one other case, sad tenants may cause much more stress. SatoMa names an expertise the place a tenant continually complained about minor points and threatened authorized motion. For instance, tenants could complain that you just’ve overcharged their lease or that you just aren’t sustaining the property appropriately. Some of these threats are completely different, and probably extra worrying than complaints about different tenants or upkeep wants.
Sadly, it’s attainable for tenants to take advantage of the legislation if the owner doesn’t have a powerful lease settlement that displays an understanding of all native and federal legal guidelines. They will drag you to court docket, require you to rack up authorized bills, and even keep away from paying lease or leaving your property.
Keep away from
The easiest way to stop having a tenant who tries to legally or financially manipulate you is by utilizing an intensive tenant screening system. Set up clear communication traces, hold observe of communication with troublesome tenants, and supply lease receipts and documentation at each alternative.
It’s additionally important that you just perceive your rights and your renters’ rights and tasks. Have a lawyer create or look over your lease earlier than sending it to tenants to be sure you cowl your state legal guidelines and adjust to the Truthful Housing Act.
To start out studying in regards to the legal guidelines in every state, learn our information: Landlord Tenant Legal guidelines by State: Renter’s Rights & Compliance.
9. An Unapproved Renovation
In a single rental property, the kitchen was newly renovated, and a tenant moved in shortly after. Just some months later, Actual Property Administration took over administration and arrived on the property to introduce themselves to the tenant. They had been shocked to search out that the tenant had determined she didn’t just like the renovation and was going to redo it herself. Sadly, she then deserted the mission and the property.
Keep away from
Each landlords and tenants ought to totally talk in regards to the state of the property initially of the lease and your expectations for the property on the finish of the lease time period. Put on and tear is regular for all properties, however there’s a clear distinction between typical put on and tear versus property injury. This communication would most certainly have prevented this example.
10. Incorrect Hire Funds
When Beth Martin began renting out a property for the primary time, her tenants would repeatedly write their checks incorrectly in order that they had been uncashable. As well as, the identical tenants would incessantly give them checks that bounced. This triggered the landlords to spend extra time and vitality contacting the tenants, ready for a brand new test, then taking it again to the financial institution.
Keep away from
Beth would cost charges for late lease, however she realized to look extra critically into potential tenants’ capability to pay. This info needs to be a part of your tenant screening course of, however you may as well decide a tenant’s lack of ability to pay to your property on the applying in the event you ask the precise questions.
Begin by utilizing our free rental utility kind templates and studying what to incorporate to study details about potential tenants.
11. Renter With an Alias
Realtor Joshua Steppling had a tenant who occurred to be a licensed contractor. When the tenant requested if he may renovate the toilet, Joshua agreed underneath the situation that he adopted the lease phrases. Sadly, a job that was alleged to take two weeks become two months, and the tenant began making late lease funds.
The subsequent month, the tenant immediately broke the lease and moved out with out contacting him, leaving the toilet fully demolished. Finally, Joshua found that his tenant had used an alias in his rental utility as a result of he had been evicted earlier than and had a file of defrauding subcontractors in one other state.
Keep away from
Joshua says that this expertise taught him to set agency standards when reviewing rental functions and to have fixed open communication with tenants about renovations. As well as, he recommends utilizing a tenant screening service to test an applicant’s Social Safety quantity, prison historical past, and credit score test. This service would have caught the alias and prevented the issue.

Tenant screening background test (Supply: Buildium)
Buildium is a property administration software program that features an easy-to-use tenant screening device. It runs a background test that screens every potential tenant’s prison historical past, eviction historical past, and credit score. It’s also possible to set customized credit score rating necessities for every property you personal, and Buildium will robotically make suggestions for candidates. Be taught extra about how Buildium makes tenant screening simple.
12. The Sublet Scammer
Subletting or subleasing is when your tenant rents the property they’re at present renting to a 3rd celebration. It isn’t unlawful, however SatoMa factors out that it may grow to be a tenant horror story if it’s not managed properly. Some tenants could even sublease the property with out your consent or data, leaving you with unauthorized occupants in your rental property and numerous potential legal responsibility points.
Keep away from
Though you may’t forestall dishonesty from all your tenants, you may massively reduce down on this downside by clearly stating in your lease settlement whether or not subletting is allowed or not. If permitted, require written permission and set up clear guidelines and tips. One other method to forestall this from turning into a good larger downside is by doing common property inspections and speaking along with your tenants.
Ensure you know how you can forestall different widespread scams by studying 15 Tenant Scams Each Landlord Must Know & Keep away from Them.
13. Felony Vandalism
It’s, sadly, fairly widespread for landlords to share tenant horror tales that contain property injury. Nevertheless, David Haberfeld had a real nightmare tenant that left injury so intense that it was featured on the native information and was thought-about felony vandalism by the police.
David shared the story in a Fb publish, naming how he tried to construct a relationship together with his tenant by shopping for him dinner and drinks and politely setting boundaries. Nevertheless, the tenant refused to pay lease for 14 months earlier than being evicted and getting a warrant for his arrest.
Keep away from
David shared that he knew this tenant was a convicted felon, and he selected to present him a second likelihood by renting this condominium. If you happen to don’t have the monetary bandwidth to deal with dangerous tenants, it’s unwise to pick a questionable tenant. Nevertheless, there are lots of instances when chances are you’ll give a possible tenant the advantage of the doubt and discover that they’re an amazing match to your property.
One of many advantages of investing in actual property is that you may make these selections for your self and probably give somebody the prospect they want. Nevertheless, totally checking the background and credit score of a potential tenant offers you a greater concept of who might be residing in your property.
Backside Line
Tenant horror tales are sometimes a preferred dialog subject, however coping with the implications as a landlord or investor is one thing to keep away from. Keep away from dangerous tenants by implementing clear and detailed lease agreements, fostering a constructive relationship along with your tenants, and establishing communication traces.