Obtain free London mayoral election updates
We’ll ship you a myFT Every day Digest electronic mail rounding up the most recent London mayoral election information each morning.
The author is a senior fellow on the Institute for Authorities
Being mayor of London needs to be one of the enticing political jobs on the planet. Huge private mandate. World metropolis. Nationwide profile. Comparatively few duties and powerful re-election prospects.
And but, subsequent Could Londoners can be supplied a alternative between a 3rd time period for Sadiq Khan (at loggerheads with the Labour management for, as they see it, costing them the Uxbridge by-election) and the Conservative contender, Susan Corridor. A councillor from the suburb of Harrow turned London Meeting member, Corridor is hardly a giant identify on the nationwide stage. The few former ministers whose names had been floated to face on a Tory ticket — comparable to Sajid Javid and Justine Greening — by no means made it from hypothesis to choice.
Given these frontrunners, the time is ripe for an impartial candidate. Earlier than Covid postponed the 2020 mayoral race by a 12 months, former Conservative MP and minister Rory Stewart, now out of the get together, supposed to run as an impartial. In 2000 Ken Livingstone, denied the nomination as Labour candidate, knocked out his official opponent within the first spherical of vote counting and prevailed over Tory challenger Steve Norris within the second. He remained in Metropolis Corridor for 2 phrases.
Livingstone’s shock success, a rebuke to Tony Blair that made entrance pages world wide, was enabled by the voting system the New Labour authorities launched when it established the mayoralty. The supplementary vote system, which supplies voters a second choice, has been used for the election of metro and mixed authority mayors and police and crime commissioners throughout England and Wales ever since. Voters can use their first vote to precise their actual choice — and, if they’re savvy sufficient to work out who will get by to the ultimate two, then selected another or a least worst possibility. It’s a compressed model of France’s two-rounds vote for president.
However subsequent 12 months’s elections can be completely different. The federal government amended final 12 months’s Elections Act to impose first previous the submit, in step with UK common elections. Labour opposition was muted. Ministers claimed the system was “overcomplicated and complicated”. And a few folks did waste their supplementary vote by failing to foretell who could be the ultimate two.
However, critically, the winner in mayoral and police commissioner races was not all the time the one who would have received beneath FPTP. In two-thirds of contests, the final word victor was an impartial or smaller get together candidate positioned second after the primary spherical. The success of the climate-focused “Teals” in final 12 months’s Australian parliamentary elections, held beneath the choice vote, confirmed the potential for preferential voting methods to let outsiders in. It’s no shock that main events favor a system that helps shield their monopoly on energy. The hurdle to any outdoors challenger for London has turn into a lot larger — few can be tempted.
There are wider implications, too. Beneath the earlier system for selecting the mayor, the necessity to hit 50 per cent of the ultimate tally meant events sought out candidates with enchantment past their core voters. It was one rationale for David Cameron persuading Boris Johnson to run efficiently in 2008, giving him a springboard to Downing Avenue within the course of.
Broader help helps in workplace — mayors need to work with different events domestically and infrequently with a authorities of a special complexion. They should stand as much as nationwide leaders of the identical get together if nationwide insurance policies don’t match native pursuits. A wider native mandate provides them legitimacy.
The power to function above and past get together is a trademark of essentially the most profitable mayors. Each Labour and the Conservatives declare mayors are key to the devolution agenda. We occurred on a system that labored to present them extra clout and with barely any debate we have now now disbursed with it. London politics would be the poorer.